Telegram RegisterThe public register of Telegram
Telegram profile photo for دیدگاه شیعه | Shia idea

Channel

دیدگاه شیعه | Shia idea

@shiaidea

On this record: Topic · Previous handles · Observations · Channels linked by matching posts · Growth · Engagement · Posts · Citations · Cite this entry

1,352subscribers

-12 since we began measuring on 5 August 2026

Risers and fallers across the register · movement among entries of 1,000–3,162.

Register entry

Telegram ID-1001007750219
TypeChannel
Username@shiaidea
CreatedBetween 1 September 2015 and 31 December 2015 — estimated from Telegram’s id allocation, not measured. How this range is calculated.
First recorded6 August 2026
Last confirmed live12 November 2026
Measurements held22
Confirmed unchanged2 times, most recently 12 November 2026
On Telegramt.me/shiaidea

Topic

Religion — a classification, not a measurement. An on-box language model (Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-FP8, prompt version 1) read this channel’s own recent posts on 18 September 2026 and assigned it the closest of 31 fixed categories, at 100% confidence. This is a model’s judgement about what the channel is likely to be about, not a fact this register measured the way a subscriber count or a view count is measured — it can be revised on a later pass, and it carries no weight anywhere else on this page. How this classification works, and the other topics.

Previous handles

Recorded in 2019 as “دیدگاه شیعه...Shia idea” — the title held for this same channel (matched by Telegram id, not by handle) in the Pushshift Telegram Dataset, a third-party archive captured in 2019-2020, years before this register made its own first observation. CC BY 4.0, Baumgartner, Zannettou, Squire & Blackburn (2020), Zenodo. A third party’s dated snapshot, not a measurement this register made itself.

Observations

These are measurements, not verdicts. Each one below states something we counted, alongside the evidence it was counted from, so you can check it rather than take it. None of them is graded: every observation this register holds is recorded at severity 0, because the precision of the detectors behind them has not been measured yet, and a rating we cannot support is worse than none. Read each as a fact about the data, not as a judgement about the channel. How we measure.

Content that also appears on other registered channels

Posts published here appear in near-verbatim form on 1 other registered channel. This entry also forms a group of 2 channels linked by matching posts. The matching is on the text itself, not on Telegram’s forward marker, so it finds a copy whether or not it was labelled as one.

Matching posts — open both and compare (2 of the pairs behind the counts below)
Posted firstThenOverlapGap
@ziaarataashoora/782 Feb 2026, 05:28 UTC@shiaidea/18782 · this entry2 Feb 2026, 05:29 UTC1.0072 seconds
@ziaarataashoora/799 Jun 2026, 11:11 UTC@shiaidea/18784 · this entry9 Jun 2026, 11:30 UTC1.0018 minutes
Channels this entry shares post bodies with, where at least one matching post pair has no forward credit between the two channels, or to a common source, recorded in our data
ChannelMatching postsText overlapTypical gapPublished first
@ziaarataashoora19 (8/8 hand-verifiable sample passed)1.00under a minutethis entry (13–6)

Text overlap is the Jaccard coefficient over the set of distinct three-word phrases in the two bodies: 1.00 is identical wording, and the threshold for counting a pair at all is 0.70. Candidates are generated by simhash LSH (4 x 16-bit bands, exact Hamming <= 3) verified against the bodies with Jaccard over the SET of distinct 3-word shingles. Published first counts which side of each matching pair carries the earlier timestamp — in this corpus, which is the limitation directly below.

What this cannot establish

MEASURED, DOMINANT ERROR SOURCE: a post ingested before 2026-08-06 may have carried a forward header that was not recorded. A 45-pair hand-check against live t.me pages found 14 (31%) where the live page shows a forward header naming the other channel and the database has none, plus 4 more (9%) naming a third party. The text match itself was wrong 0 times out of 45. Read attribution_capture.items_in_trusted_window before treating the unattributed count as a claim.

Telegram lets a channel forward a post with a header naming the source, and we only began reliably recording that header on 2026-08-06. None of the 4 matches recorded here fall after that date, so for this entry we cannot say whether any of them carried a credit. The duplication is measured; the absence of attribution is not.

“Published first” means first in this corpus. We hold 20 comparable posts for this entry, running 7 August 2025 to 12 June 2026. A channel we have read one page deep will look younger than a neighbour we have read in full, and the order would flip with no change in the underlying facts.

The detector’s own notes on this observation, as it recorded them. Names in this_style are fields of the underlying evidence record, which the plain-English paragraphs above read out for this entry.

  • Verbatim republication has three causes and the text separates only two: a clone/mirror, unattributed copy-paste, or BOTH channels copying a common third source that neither attributes. The spread filter (content held by at most 8 channels) reduces the third and does not remove it.
  • 'Earliest' means earliest IN THIS CORPUS. A channel ingested one page deep will look younger than a neighbour ingested in full; corpus_coverage above is there to be checked before the direction is believed.
  • shared_verified_est extrapolates the sampled pass rate over the full narrow match count; sampled/passed are the numbers actually measured.
  • Absence of a forward header is not proof of intent: Telegram lets a channel disable forward attribution, and a credit written in the body is not parsed as attribution here (mention_edge_either_way above is the closest available signal).

Of the group of 2 channels, the one whose matching posts we hold earliest is @ziaarataashoora. That is a statement about our reading window, not a claim of authorship.

Recorded under the key clone_mutual, last confirmed 11 November 2026. An observation that a later pass no longer finds is cleared, and a cleared observation is removed from this page rather than being shown struck through — we do not keep publishing a claim we have withdrawn. Dispute an observation.

Channels linked by matching posts

This channel is in a group of 2 registered channels linked by matching posts. Links are found by comparing text fingerprints across every channel on the register.

Which channel, if either, published first is deliberately not shown in this list. “First” could only mean first in our own crawl, which depends on how deep we happened to reach into each channel’s history, not on when the content was actually first posted. Our one hand-check read 45 of the highest-confidence flagged pairs against the live Telegram pages. In 18 of them the live page showed a “Forwarded from” credit that our database had no record of, so reading that pair as an unattributed copy was wrong; the check did not measure who published first. This list is ordered by subscriber count, the same as every other listing on this site, never by which channel we think came first. Near-verbatim matching has several ordinary explanations besides copying — a channel mirroring itself, an unattributed repost, or two channels independently repeating the same wire story — and this measurement cannot tell those apart. How this is measured.

Growth

1,3521,3651,358.55 August 2026 — 1,364 subscribers6 August 2026 — 1,364 subscribers6 August 2026 — 1,365 subscribers12 August 2026 — 1,363 subscribers16 August 2026 — 1,364 subscribers18 August 2026 — 1,365 subscribers22 August 2026 — 1,364 subscribers28 August 2026 — 1,365 subscribers31 August 2026 — 1,364 subscribers11 September 2026 — 1,363 subscribers25 September 2026 — 1,358 subscribers4 October 2026 — 1,357 subscribers10 October 2026 — 1,356 subscribers14 October 2026 — 1,358 subscribers17 October 2026 — 1,357 subscribers21 October 2026 — 1,355 subscribers23 October 2026 — 1,356 subscribers26 October 2026 — 1,358 subscribers29 October 2026 — 1,356 subscribers1 November 2026 — 1,355 subscribers4 November 2026 — 1,354 subscribers8 November 2026 — 1,352 subscribers5 August 20268 November 2026
22 measurements spanning 94 days, net -12. Dots are measurements; the straight line between them is drawn to join them, not to claim we know the path taken in between — snapshots are recorded only when a count changes, so gaps mean “no change observed”, never “interpolated”. The vertical axis spans 1,350–1,367 and does not start at zero.
Measurement log — every subscribers count we have recorded, most recent 20 of 22
Measured (UTC)SubscribersChange
8 Nov 2026, 07:061,352-2
4 Nov 2026, 21:461,354-1
1 Nov 2026, 15:301,355-1
29 Oct 2026, 15:561,356-2
26 Oct 2026, 20:581,358+2
23 Oct 2026, 17:361,356+1
21 Oct 2026, 00:491,355-2
17 Oct 2026, 16:151,357-1
14 Oct 2026, 15:071,358+2
10 Oct 2026, 22:391,356-1
4 Oct 2026, 23:211,357-1
25 Sept 2026, 18:571,358-5
11 Sept 2026, 18:191,363-1
31 Aug 2026, 00:061,364-1
28 Aug 2026, 05:271,365+1
22 Aug 2026, 01:471,364-1
18 Aug 2026, 23:141,365+1
16 Aug 2026, 04:561,364+1
12 Aug 2026, 10:151,363-2
6 Aug 2026, 13:521,365first reading

Engagement

20 posts held, back to 7 August 2025 — the reader has not yet reached the start of this channel’s public history, so older posts may sit further back, unread. Read across 1 page of Telegram’s post history, 20 posts per page.

Nothing published in the last 30 days. ERR and ER are rolling 30-day measures, so there is nothing to compute — we hold 20 posts for this entry, the most recent from 12 June 2026. An engagement rate over an empty window would be a number about nothing.

Recent posts

12 Jun 2026, 07:52 UTC≈222 viewsread 6 August 2026
File

🔺 فهرست و مقدمۀ 🔻 ترجمۀ انگلیسی کتاب «زیارت عاشورا از آغاز تا امروز» رابط خرید کتاب در سایت بین‌المللی آمازون 🌐 @ziaarataashoora

12 Jun 2026, 07:52 UTC≈294 viewsread 6 August 2026

. 🛑 ترجمۀ انگلیسی کتاب «زیارت عاشورا از آغاز تا امروز» منتشر شد. Ziyārat ʿĀshūrāʾ Between Taqiyya and Tabarrī: A Study on Manuscript Transmission by Sayyid Mahdi Mahmoudi (Author), Mostafa Movahedifar (Editor) Format: Paperback "O God, I seek nearness to You on this day, in this position of mine, and throughout the days of my life, through disassociation from them and cursing them, and through loyalty to Your Pr…

9 Jun 2026, 11:30 UTC≈247 viewsread 6 August 2026
File

. 🔺 نقد مقالۀ «تحلیل و نقد یکی از فقره‌های نسخۀ رایج زیارت عاشورا» 🔹 پژوهش‌نامۀ معارف حسینی 🔹 دورۀ ۱۱، شمارۀ ۴۲ ✍️ سید مهدی محمودی 🔘 چکیده ▫️سال‌هاست فقرۀ پایانیِ زیارت عاشورای مشهور، ذهن اندیشمندان را به خود مشغول کرده است. برخی برای «عدم اصالت» آن دلایلی ارائه کرده‌اند و پاسخ‌هایی به آنان داده شده است. ▫️در مقالۀ «تحلیل و نقد یکی از فقره‌های نسخۀ رایج زیارت عاشورا» ــ که در سال ۱۳۹۲ در دوفصلنامۀ …

6 Feb 2026, 11:06 UTC≈488 viewsread 6 August 2026
File

. 🔺 روش‌شناسی تألیف کتاب مکیال المکارم 🎙 سید مهدی محمودی 🔹 دبیر نشست: عطاءالله اسماعیلی 📌 سرای اهل قلم، خانۀ کتاب و ادبیات ایران ⌛️ ۱۲ بهمن ۱۴۰۴ https://ketab.ir/News/33469 .:: Shia idea...دیدگاه شیعه ::. 🌐 telegram.me/shiaidea

2 Feb 2026, 05:29 UTC≈519 viewsread 6 August 2026
File

. 🔺 مقالۀ پژوهشی فقرۀ پایانی در زیارت عاشورا، الحاقی یا اصیل؟ 🔹 پژوهش‌نامۀ معارف حسینی 🔹 دورۀ ۱۱، شمارۀ ۴۱ ✍️ سید مهدی محمودی 🔘 چکیده 🔹 برخی ادعا کرده‌اند لعن‌های پایانی زیارت عاشورای مشهور، در اصل در این زیارت موجود نبوده و از دوران صفویه به بعد به مصباح‌المتهجد، تألیف شیخ طوسی قدس‌سره (م۴۶۰ق) افزوده و در نتیجه زیارت عاشورا تحریف شده است! مهم‌ترین دلایل مدعیان، برای اثبات تحریف در زیارت عاشورای مشه…

29 Aug 2025, 06:54 UTC≈862 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥اصالت زیارت عاشورای مشهور، براساس نسخه مهم ابن سکون حلی(ره) 🔻جایگاه ابن سکون حلی، جایگاه بسیار بزرگی است؛ نسخه‌های کتابت‌شده به‌وسیله این فقیه و عالم بزرگ شیعه آن‌قدر دارای اهمیت است که اگر یک نسخه خطی حتی با دو یا سه واسطه از روی نسخه ابن سکون کتابت شده یا با خط او مقابله شده باشد، برای ما دارای اعتبار می‌شود. عموم نسخه‌های معتبر صحیفـۀ سجادیه و نهج‌البلاغه، اعتبار خود را از مقابله با خط ابن سکون کسب کرده است. عبا…

29 Aug 2025, 06:54 UTC≈707 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥اشکال بلاغی در عبارات پایانی زیارت عاشورا در کامل‌الزیارت و یک تذکر مهم 🔹️کسانی که تأکید دارند: زیارت عاشورا را از کامل‌الزیارات بخوانید، زیرا معتبرتر و کهن‌تر است؛ البته ما هم در قدمت و اعتبار کامل‌الزیارات اشکالی نداریم؛ اما اگر احتمال تقیه پیش آمد، آن‌گاه نقل این کتاب در موضع احتمال تقیه از اعتبار ساقط خواهد شد. #زیارت_عاشورا_از_آغاز_تا_امروز iqna.ir/00I2Lr @iqnanews

29 Aug 2025, 06:54 UTC≈578 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥اشکال مفهومی عبارت پایانی زیارت عاشورا در کامل‌الزیارات ▫️زیارت عاشورا یکی از پرمحتواترین و اثرگذارترین متون زیارتی شیعه است؛ متنی که نه فقط سوگ، بلکه سوگند به ادامه راه حق را در دل خود دارد. مجموعه درس‌گفتار «زیارت عاشورا؛ از آغاز تا امروز» نگاهی تحلیلی و روشمند به مفاهیم بنیادین نهضت سیدالشهدا(ع) است. 🎙کارشناسی حجت‌الاسلام سیدمهدی محمودی، پژوهشگر دینی و نویسنده کتاب «زیارت عاشورا؛ از آغاز تا امروز» #زیارت_عاشورا…

19 Aug 2025, 08:35 UTC≈624 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥شواهد تقیه در کامل‌الزیارات ابن قولویه ▫️زیارت عاشورا یکی از پرمحتواترین و اثرگذارترین متون زیارتی شیعه است؛ متنی که نه فقط سوگ، بلکه سوگند به ادامه راه حق را در دل خود دارد. مجموعه درس‌گفتار «زیارت عاشورا؛ از آغاز تا امروز» نگاهی تحلیلی و روشمند به مفاهیم بنیادین نهضت سیدالشهدا(ع) است. 🎙کارشناسی حجت‌الاسلام سیدمهدی محمودی، پژوهشگر دینی و نویسنده کتاب «زیارت عاشورا؛ از آغاز تا امروز» #زیارت_عاشورا_از_آغاز_تا_امروز…

19 Aug 2025, 08:35 UTC≈496 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥تطبیق عبارت «ابن آکله الاکباد» بر یزید ▫️در زیارت عاشورا می‌خوانیم: اللهم ان هذا یوم تبرکت به بنو امیه و ابن آکله الاکباد العین بن اللعین؛ در این عبارت آکله الاکباد و ابن آکله الاکباد مورد لعن قرار گرفته‌اند و این تصور وجود دارد که مراد از ابن آکله، معاویه باشد که فرزند هند جگرخوار است. اگر معاویه مورد تقیه شیخ طوسی بوده است نباید این تعبیر می‌آمد. #زیارت_عاشورا_از_آغاز_تا_امروز iqna.ir/00I2JI @iqnanews

17 Aug 2025, 03:55 UTC≈520 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥تقیه شیخ طوسی (ره) با حذف گسترده در عبارات پایانی زیارت عاشورا 🔹شیخ طوسی بخش پایانی زیارت عاشورا را به صورت نسبتا گسترده حذف کرده است تا شیعیان متوجه شوند در اینجا اتفاقی افتاده است و آن اتفاق تقیه مؤلف کتاب است. #زیارت_عاشورا_از_آغاز_تا_امروز iqna.ir/00I1rf @iqnanews

17 Aug 2025, 03:55 UTC≈499 viewsread 6 August 2026
Forwarded from @iqnanewsVideo

🎥بازخوانی یک روایت مشکوک درباره شیخ طوسی ▫️زیارت عاشورا یکی از پرمحتواترین و اثرگذارترین متون زیارتی شیعه است؛ متنی که نه فقط سوگ، بلکه سوگند به ادامه راه حق را در دل خود دارد. مجموعه درس‌گفتار «زیارت عاشورا؛ از آغاز تا امروز» نگاهی تحلیلی و روشمند به مفاهیم بنیادین نهضت سیدالشهدا(ع) است. 🎙کارشناسی حجت‌الاسلام سیدمهدی محمودی، پژوهشگر دینی و نویسنده کتاب «زیارت عاشورا؛ از آغاز تا امروز» #زیارت_عاشورا_از_آغاز_تا_امرو…

Showing the 12 most recent of 20 posts we hold for @shiaidea. View and reaction counts are the latest single reading for each post, not a live figure, and a recent post is still accumulating both. A view count marked ≈ was rounded by Telegram before we ever saw it — t.me prints views in full below 1,000 and to three significant figures above, so ≈1,200,000 means somewhere between 1,150,000 and 1,249,999. Unmarked counts are exact. Text is reproduced from the public post preview and truncated for length.

Forward network

Republished by

Channels on the register that have forwarded this channel's posts into their own feed.

Republishes

Channels on the register whose posts this channel has forwarded.

Built only from forwarded posts we have actually read, on both sides. Coverage is early and deliberately incomplete: a missing link means we have not read the post that would prove it, never that the relationship does not exist. Counts are distinct forwarded posts observed, so they only ever go up as we read more.

Mentions

A mention is a weaker signal than a forward and is counted separately for that reason — naming a channel is not republishing it, and a handle in a post body is easy to place deliberately. The post counts beside each row below are distinct posts in which the handle appeared, from posts we have read on both sides — the “Named by N registered channels” figure above is a different count, of distinct NAMING CHANNELS rather than posts, and is not the sum of the rows under it.

Cite this entry

A live page changes as we take new readings, so a citation should name the measurement it is based on, not just the URL. The line below cites the subscriber count as measured 8 November 2026 — this entry's latest reading, not the date you are reading this.

“دیدگاه شیعه | Shia idea” (@shiaidea), 1,352 subscribers as measured 8 November 2026. Telegram Register, tgregister.com/channel/shiaidea.

Full measurement history, CC BY 4.0. Every reading this register holds for this entry, not just the latest one, as a dated, downloadable record: CSV · JSON. Free to use with attribution to tgregister.com. Each file carries its own generation timestamp, which is the figure to cite for exactly when the data was retrieved.