The account of the user that owns this channel has been inactive for the last 5 months. If it remains inactive in the next 20 days, that account will self-destruct and this channel may no longer have an owner.

Channel
کشکول
@estebsar
On this record: Growth · Engagement · What this channel posts · Posts · Polls · Citations · Cite this entry
22subscribers
+0 since we began measuring on 6 August 2026
Risers and fallers across the register · movement among entries of Under 1,000.
Register entry
| Telegram ID | -1001080079467 |
|---|---|
| Type | Channel |
| Username | @estebsar |
| Description | فلسفه و علم، عرفان و ادیان، هنر و موسیقی، متافیزیک و اونتولوژی |
| Created | Between 1 September 2016 and 30 September 2017— estimated from Telegram’s id allocation, not measured. How this range is calculated. |
| First recorded | 11 August 2026 |
| Last confirmed live | 13 August 2026 |
| Measurements held | 2 |
| On Telegram | t.me/estebsar |
Growth
| Measured (UTC) | Subscribers | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 11 Aug 2026, 12:34 | 22 | no change |
| 6 Aug 2026, 01:12 | 22 | first reading |
Engagement
20 posts held, back to 4 April 2020 — the reader has not yet reached the start of this channel’s public history, so older posts may sit further back, unread. Read across 1 pageof Telegram’s post history, 20 posts per page.
Nothing published in the last 30 days. ERR and ER are rolling 30-day measures, so there is nothing to compute — we hold 20 posts for this entry, the most recent from 16 January 2022. An engagement rate over an empty window would be a number about nothing.
What this channel posts
- Photos
- 296
- Videos
- 37
- Links
- 339
Lifetime counters from Telegram’s own channel header, read 11 August 2026 — not the date at the top of this page, which is when the subscriber count was last read. Below Telegram’s rounding threshold, so these counts are exact.
Recent posts
The account of the user that owns this channel has been inactive for the last 5 months. If it remains inactive in the next 30 days, that account will self-destruct and this channel may no longer have an owner.
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-05-07 #مفاهیم_جایگزین_برای_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیقت #سارا_کوکلی @estebsar
🎓لطفاً تنها واجدان تحصیلات دانشگاهی پاسخ دهند: ❓ارتباط شما با دین چگونه است؟
- 🔻بیدین بودم و سپس به دین گرویدم.4%
- 🔻دین خانوادگیام را بیوقفه و با قوت ادامه میدهم.33%
- 🔻در عین پیروی از دینم، تردید دارم.13%
- 🔻تغییر دین دادهام و از یک دین مشخص به دین مشخص دیگری گرویدهام.1%
- 🔻دیندارم اما از یک دین واحد و مشخصی پیروی نمیکنم؛ بلکه اجزای ایمانم را از ادیان مختلف برمیگزینم.11%
- 🔻ندانمگرا هستم و اطمینان ندارم که دیندار باشم یا بیدین.11%
- 🔻برای دین اهمیتی قائل نیستم و با آن اظهار موافقت با مخالفت نمیکنم.10%
- 🔻دین را زیانآور میدانم و با آن مخالفت میورزم.18%
Shares as published, totalling 101%. No per-option vote count is published by Telegram, so none is shown.
https://telegra.ph/Does-God-Exist-04-26 #آیا_خدایی_هست؟ #سد_گورو @estebsar
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-04-26 #مفاهیم_جایگزین_برای_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیقت #اریک_اشتینهارت @estebsar
📊 آیا خدا را همان هستی/وجود در معنای فلسفی میدانید؟ (لطفاً با نشر در گروههای معرفتی، به دامنهٔ این استقرا بیفزایید.)
- آری.39%
- مطمئن نیستم.23%
- خیر؛ خدا را در معنایی دیگر میپذیرم (اعتقاد و یا ایمان دارم).30%
- خیر؛ خدا را در هیچ معنایی نمیپذیرم (فاقد اعتقاد و یا ایمانام).3%
- به بودونبود خدا و معنای او اهمیت نمیدهم.6%
Shares as published, totalling 101%. No per-option vote count is published by Telegram, so none is shown.
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-04-24-2 #مفاهیم_جایگزین_برای_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیقت #مایکل_لوین @estebsar
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-04-24 #مفاهیم_جایگزین_برای_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیقت #شلنبرگ @estebsar
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-04-20 #مفاهیم_جایگزین_برای_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیقت #یوجین_ناگاساوا @estebsar
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-04-19 #تصویر_کلان_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیفت #مایکل_تولی @estebsar
https://telegra.ph/Closer-to-truth-04-18 #تصویر_کلان_خدا #نزدیکتر_به_حقیفت #ونزل_هویستین @estebsar
Showing the 12 most recent of 20 posts we hold for @estebsar. View and reaction counts are the latest single reading for each post, not a live figure, and a recent post is still accumulating both. A view count marked ≈ was rounded by Telegram before we ever saw it — t.me prints views in full below 1,000 and to three significant figures above, so ≈1,200,000 means somewhere between 1,150,000 and 1,249,999. Unmarked counts are exact. Text is reproduced from the public post preview and truncated for length.
Polls
The 2 polls we hold for this entry, as Telegram rendered them when we read the post. A poll’s figures keep moving after that, so each one is dated.
🎓لطفاً تنها واجدان تحصیلات دانشگاهی پاسخ دهند: ❓ارتباط شما با دین چگونه است؟
- 🔻بیدین بودم و سپس به دین گرویدم.4%
- 🔻دین خانوادگیام را بیوقفه و با قوت ادامه میدهم.33%
- 🔻در عین پیروی از دینم، تردید دارم.13%
- 🔻تغییر دین دادهام و از یک دین مشخص به دین مشخص دیگری گرویدهام.1%
- 🔻دیندارم اما از یک دین واحد و مشخصی پیروی نمیکنم؛ بلکه اجزای ایمانم را از ادیان مختلف برمیگزینم.11%
- 🔻ندانمگرا هستم و اطمینان ندارم که دیندار باشم یا بیدین.11%
- 🔻برای دین اهمیتی قائل نیستم و با آن اظهار موافقت با مخالفت نمیکنم.10%
- 🔻دین را زیانآور میدانم و با آن مخالفت میورزم.18%
Shares as published, totalling 101%. No per-option vote count is published by Telegram, so none is shown.
📊 آیا خدا را همان هستی/وجود در معنای فلسفی میدانید؟ (لطفاً با نشر در گروههای معرفتی، به دامنهٔ این استقرا بیفزایید.)
- آری.39%
- مطمئن نیستم.23%
- خیر؛ خدا را در معنایی دیگر میپذیرم (اعتقاد و یا ایمان دارم).30%
- خیر؛ خدا را در هیچ معنایی نمیپذیرم (فاقد اعتقاد و یا ایمانام).3%
- به بودونبود خدا و معنای او اهمیت نمیدهم.6%
Shares as published, totalling 101%. No per-option vote count is published by Telegram, so none is shown.
Percentages only — there are no per-option vote counts here, because Telegram publishes none.The public post preview gives each option’s share and a single voter total, and nothing else. Multiplying one by the other would produce a per-option tally that looks measured and is not: the shares are rounded to whole numbers before we ever see them. We print what was published and leave the column that does not exist empty.
The shares need not add up to 100.Rounding alone puts many polls at 99 or 101. A poll that allows more than one answer per voter runs well past 100 by design, and several here do. The bars are drawn against a fixed 100% track at each option’s own percentage rather than normalised to the total, so a poll that exceeds it shows that it does instead of being quietly rescaled.
Read from the 20 most recent posts we hold, published 4 April 2020 to 16 January 2022. Telegram labels each poll by kind — an anonymous poll, a quiz, a closed set of final results — and that label is reproduced rather than paraphrased.
Forward network
Republishes
Channels on the register whose posts this channel has forwarded.
Built only from forwarded posts we have actually read, on both sides. Coverage is early and deliberately incomplete: a missing link means we have not read the post that would prove it, never that the relationship does not exist. Counts are distinct forwarded posts observed, so they only ever go up as we read more.
Cite this entry
A live page changes as we take new readings, so a citation should name the measurement it is based on, not just the URL. The line below cites the subscriber count as measured 11 August 2026 — this entry's latest reading, not the date you are reading this.
“کشکول” (@estebsar), 22 subscribers as measured 11 August 2026. Telegram Register, tgregister.com/channel/estebsar.
Full measurement history, CC BY 4.0. Every reading this register holds for this entry, not just the latest one, as a dated, downloadable record: CSV · JSON. Free to use with attribution to tgregister.com. Each file carries its own generation timestamp, which is the figure to cite for exactly when the data was retrieved.