1 Aug 2026, 19:31 UTC126 views1 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(10) What We’ve Actually Been Arguing About
Ask anyone why they oppose Islamic corporal punishment, and some version of the same word shows up almost immediately: barbaric.
It’s not a conclusion. It’s a conversa…
❤1
27 Jul 2026, 19:58 UTC163 viewsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(9) The Person the Debate Forgets
Ask someone why they oppose severe punishment, and they will tell you, almost without fail, about the offender.
His dignity. His right to a future. His capacity, however unlikel…
22 Jul 2026, 15:16 UTC162 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(8) What If Abolition Has a Body Count?
Picture two countries.
In the first, courts hand down the death penalty for murder. In the second, the harshest sentence is life without parole. Nothing else differs — sam…
❤1👍1
19 Jul 2026, 11:03 UTC167 views1 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(7) Justice, Not Revenge
One of the most effective ways to shut down a conversation about capital punishment is to call it revenge.
The word does a lot of work. It makes the desire for serious punishment sound p…
❤1
11 Jul 2026, 15:45 UTC191 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(6) These Punishments Aren’t About Pain. They’re About What Society Protects.
Once you understand how difficult conviction under Islamic criminal law actually is, a natural question follows: then why do these pun…
❤2
5 Jul 2026, 16:46 UTC236 views1 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(5b) Deterrence Without Application
Here is the objection worth taking seriously: if everyone knows conviction under the ḥadd (the fixed, legislatively prescribed penalty) is nearly impossible, doesn’t that knowl…
❤1
3 Jul 2026, 13:08 UTC212 views1 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(5a) Mercy Built Into the Architecture: When in Doubt, Let Go
The hudūd (fixed penalties prescribed by Islamic law for specific serious offences) do not need Western legal theory to justify them. They stand on di…
❤1
27 Jun 2026, 11:34 UTC241 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(4) The Maths of Justice: Why Severe Punishments Weren’t Irrational
Here is a simple equation the philosopher Jeremy Bentham, the philosopher most associated with modern utilitarian thinking,
used to think about …
❤1👍1
20 Jun 2026, 16:54 UTC220 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(3) The Fiction of Merciful Incarceration:
The assumption that the prison is the civilised alternative to physical punishment has never really been argued. It has simply been asserted — repeatedly, confidently, a…
❤1👍1
14 Jun 2026, 18:13 UTC231 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(2) The Carceral Illusion: The Prison Didn’t Replace Cruelty. It Hid It.
In 1975, French philosopher Michel Foucault published Discipline and Punish — and what he argued should unsettle anyone who takes the human…
❤1👍1
7 Jun 2026, 19:56 UTC251 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| THE HUDUD FILES ||
A multi-part series examining Islamic criminal law, Western criminology, and the philosophy of punishment — and asking whether the West’s answer to justice actually holds up.
(1) Series Introduction: Punishment, Power, and Moral Order
There is a peculiar confidence with which modern societies declare the prison the pinnacle of civilised punishment. The cell, the sentence, the parole b…
❤1👍1
30 May 2026, 14:34 UTC287 views2 reactionsread 6 August 2026 ⬜️⬛️
|| Beneath the Foam Lies the Ocean ||
The Prophet ﷺ said about the end of times:
بَلْ أَنْتُمْ يَوْمَئِذٍ كَثِيرٌ
“On that day you will be numerous in number…”
Yet despite their numbers, he described them as:
غُثَاءٌ كَغُثَاءِ السَّيْلِ
”…like foam, like the scum of the sea.”
[‘𝘚𝑢𝘯𝑎𝘯 𝘈𝑏𝘪 𝘋𝑎𝘸𝑢𝘥 4297, صحيح].
Look at this scene. Around 2 million pilgrims gather for Hajj 2026.
Millions of believers gather…
❤1👍1
Showing the 12 most recent of 20 posts we hold for @IntellectualHikmah. View and reaction counts are the latest single reading for each post, not a live figure, and a recent post is still accumulating both. A view count marked ≈ was rounded by Telegram before we ever saw it — t.me prints views in full below 1,000 and to three significant figures above, so ≈1,200,000 means somewhere between 1,150,000 and 1,249,999. Unmarked counts are exact. Text is reproduced from the public post preview and truncated for length.